Digital Inclusion in Agribusiness: Access, Capabilities, Market Power and Smallholder Outcomes
Sanjiv Kumar *
Faculty of Agriculture, Jagannath University, Jaipur-303901, India.
Harkesh Kumar Balai
Faculty of Agriculture, Jagannath University, Jaipur-303901, India.
Sarita Meena
Faculty of Agriculture, Jagannath University, Jaipur-303901, India.
Rajendra Bairwa
Faculty of Agriculture, Jagannath University, Jaipur-303901, India.
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Abstract
Digital technologies increasingly mediate agricultural advice, input procurement, finance, marketing and coordination across agrifood value chains, yet their availability does not necessarily confer meaningful participation on smallholders or rural enterprises. This critical narrative review examines the mechanisms through which digitalisation may reduce transaction costs and improve decision-making, alongside the socioeconomic, organisational and governance conditions that can reproduce exclusion. The review integrates experimental studies of agricultural information delivery, observational analyses of participation and livelihoods, research on digital financial services, critical accounts of platform-mediated commerce, and recent studies of inclusion-oriented design. Evidence indicates that well-designed digital advisory interventions can improve knowledge and adoption of selected practices, although effects on output, profits and sustained welfare are more variable. Access to a device or network is an inadequate proxy for inclusion because language, literacy, control over devices, household bargaining, service relevance, market infrastructure and financial risk condition the conversion of connectivity into benefits. Digital marketplaces may expand reach while imposing fees, logistical obligations or dependence on powerful intermediaries; digital finance can facilitate transactions and savings while creating new exposure to opaque credit practices. The review develops a staged, relational account of inclusion that distinguishes technical reach, effective use, economic agency, distributive outcomes and rights over data. It identifies the need for long-term, disaggregated causal evaluations; enterprise-level evidence beyond farm adoption; transparent assessment of public–private delivery models; and governance arrangements that make information quality, affordability and accountability enforceable. Bridging technology gaps requires coordinated investment in basic infrastructure, trusted human support, locally adapted services and fair commercial institutions rather than expanding digital interfaces in isolation.
Keywords: Digital divide, agricultural advisory services, rural entrepreneurship, smallholder farmers, platform governance, gender inequality, digital financial services, agrifood value chains